HorseRacing
Aidan O’Brien’s gamble to end hoodoo with City Of Troy gets lost in Californian dirt
2024-11-04
The aftermath of the Breeders' Cup Classic on Saturday saw the familiar refrain of Aidan O'Brien taking responsibility for City Of Troy's lackluster performance. However, a deeper analysis reveals a complex narrative of missed opportunities, valuable insights, and a relentless pursuit of the sport's most coveted prize.

Chasing the Elusive Breeders' Cup Classic Crown

The Pace Predicament

The Breeders' Cup Classic is a race that demands unwavering strategy and adaptability. As O'Brien noted, City Of Troy's tardy start was a significant setback, but the real story unfolded in the blistering pace that unfolded. The first half-mile was completed in a record-breaking 44.96 seconds, setting the stage for a closer to emerge victorious. Sierra Leone, the eventual winner, capitalized on this pace, steadily and smoothly making his way to the front of the pack.

For City Of Troy, the pace proved to be his undoing. The horse's inability to handle the kickback and reach the high cruising speed that had carried him to success in the International Stakes just months earlier was a testament to the challenges of transitioning from the turf to the dirt. O'Brien's self-criticism, while admirable, only scratches the surface of the complexities involved in preparing a turf-bred horse for the rigors of the Breeders' Cup Classic.

Lessons from Past Triumphs

The history of the Breeders' Cup Classic has shown that it is possible to win the prestigious event with a turf-bred horse making its debut on the dirt surface. The legendary victory of Arcangues in 1993, trained by André Fabre, serves as a testament to this fact. However, Arcangues was a seasoned five-year-old with 15 starts under his belt, and had only two unsuccessful starts since May before heading to the US.

This raises an intriguing question for O'Brien and the Coolmore syndicate: how can they maximize their chances of winning the Breeders' Cup Classic? The answer may lie in targeting a top-class, dirt-bred four-year-old whose entire season is built around the Breeders' Cup, perhaps even including a previous run on the surface. The challenge, however, lies in the fact that top-class European racing is predominantly on turf, and the owners' business plan is often centered around three-year-old Classic winners.

Resilience and Reinvention

Despite the disappointment of City Of Troy's performance, O'Brien's record in the Breeders' Cup Classic on dirt now stands at 0-16. However, as the saying goes, "you learn more from failure than you do from success." This latest reverse is sure to inform O'Brien's future attempts to break his Classic hoodoo.

The Coolmore syndicate's decision to run City Of Troy in the Breeders' Cup Classic, rather than the Turf, was a bold and ambitious move. They gambled and lost, but most punters would agree that their willingness to take on the challenge is commendable. This unwavering spirit and relentless pursuit of the sport's most coveted prize is a testament to O'Brien and Coolmore's commitment to the game.

As the curtain falls on another Breeders' Cup Classic, the lessons learned will undoubtedly shape O'Brien's future strategies. The search for the perfect formula to conquer the dirt continues, and with each setback, the determination to succeed only grows stronger. The journey may be arduous, but the potential rewards are unparalleled, and O'Brien and Coolmore have proven time and again that they are willing to go the extra mile to achieve their goals.

More Stories