The upcoming 2025 season is shaping up to be a pivotal one for both the Oakland Athletics and the San Diego Padres as they look to bolster their starting rotations. With the Athletics securing Jose LeClerc, they are now focusing on adding depth to their pitching staff by considering Marcus Stroman. Meanwhile, the Padres are exploring trade options that could bring in Stroman while also addressing financial constraints. Both teams recognize the need for reliable starters who can consistently perform over the course of a long season.

For the Athletics, adding Stroman would provide stability to their rotation, ensuring they meet league requirements and avoid potential issues with the MLBPA. Pairing him with veterans Luis Severino and Jeffrey Springs would give the team a solid foundation. Stroman's ability to make numerous starts and keep games competitive makes him an attractive option. Additionally, his contract includes a player option for 2026, which vests if he reaches 140 innings this season, offering both security and risk.

The Padres, on the other hand, find themselves above the luxury tax threshold for 2025 and are looking for ways to trim costs. A trade involving Stroman and possibly cash from another team could help them absorb his salary without exceeding financial limits. The Padres' current projected No. 4 and No. 5 starters, Randy Vasquez and Matt Waldron, may not offer the same level of certainty as Stroman. His experience and consistency make him a safer choice for a club seeking immediate improvement.

In this scenario, a swap involving Luis Arraez could benefit both teams. Arraez's unique skill set could complement the Yankees' lineup if utilized effectively. However, the most compelling fit appears to be Stroman joining the Padres' rotation, where his proven track record would address their pressing need for dependable starting pitching. This strategic move could significantly enhance both teams' rosters and position them for success in the upcoming season.