In the latest edition of the SP Roundup, an in-depth analysis of starting pitchers' performances from Thursday's games unveils a mix of triumphs and struggles. Among the standout performances is Walker Buehler, whose outing against the Blue Jays in Fenway Park showcased potential for resurgence. Despite some promising signs, doubts linger about his ability to consistently excel as a top-tier starter. Other notable performances include José Soriano's efficient pitching against the Rays, Ryan Feltner's effective four-seamer usage, and Spencer Schwellenbach's diverse arsenal. This review delves into the nuances of each pitcher's approach, effectiveness, and areas for improvement.

Walker Buehler's performance against the Toronto Blue Jays at Fenway Park was a pivotal moment in his ongoing journey to reclaim his former dominance. In this game, he pitched 6.1 innings with only one earned run, allowing four hits while striking out seven batters. His pitch repertoire included eight whiffs and a commendable 30% CSW rate, utilizing 89 pitches in total. Although his fastball velocity remains below 94 mph, the effectiveness of his secondary pitches suggests that there may be more to come from Buehler. Observers noted his determination to achieve optimal results on every pitch, yet his overall impact lacks the overwhelming dominance seen in past seasons.

José Soriano demonstrated exceptional control during his matchup against the Tampa Bay Rays, securing a win with a 7.2-inning performance. He limited the Rays to one earned run, five hits, and three walks, complemented by four strikeouts. Notably, his curveball returned with significant force, achieving a 48% CSW rate and maintaining high strike accuracy. The slider, though sparingly used, contributed effectively to his strategy. Soriano's adaptability and pitch selection highlight his readiness to face tougher opponents in upcoming games.

Ryan Feltner's start against the Milwaukee Brewers featured a remarkable reliance on his four-seamer, which garnered an impressive 16 called strikes. This pitch choice enabled him to dominate left-handed batters and execute what might be termed a "King Cole" approach. However, questions remain about the consistency of his secondary offerings, particularly the sweeper, which still presents challenges. Despite these concerns, Feltner's ability to navigate through six solid innings underscores his growing confidence and skill set.

Spencer Schwellenbach's duel with the Philadelphia Phillies highlighted his expansive arsenal, featuring a fastball reaching 96 mph, a flat attack angle, and a variety of breaking pitches. His performance, marked by ten whiffs and a 27% CSW rate, could have extended further had it not been interrupted by a rain delay. The potential within his varied pitch selection offers hope for future dominance, even if the current numbers do not fully reflect this promise.

To conclude, the collective performances reviewed here underscore the dynamic nature of baseball pitching. While some pitchers like Walker Buehler show glimpses of their former selves, others such as José Soriano and Ryan Feltner continue to evolve and refine their craft. Each pitcher brings unique strengths and challenges to the mound, contributing to the ever-changing landscape of professional baseball. As the season progresses, fans and analysts alike eagerly await further developments from these talented individuals.