Alabama's offense, led by quarterback Jalen Milroe, has been potent throughout the season. They have scored an average of 36.7 points per game and have a dynamic running game. But their defense has also had its moments of weakness, especially in the red zone. Can they overcome these flaws and make a strong case for themselves?
On the other hand, teams like SMU have had impressive seasons of their own. SMU should be rewarded for their strong regular season in their first year in the ACC. But their loss to Clemson in the ACC championship game may work against them. Will the committee give them the benefit of the doubt and include them in the playoff?
Arizona State has a better schedule with one more loss, but Boise State's only loss was to Oregon. Both teams will get first-round byes, but the question remains: who should be seeded higher? The committee will have to consider factors such as strength of schedule, head-to-head matchups, and recent performance.
Texas and Penn State also face a tough decision when it comes to seeding. The Longhorns and Nittany Lions lost their conference championship games, and there is a debate about whether two-loss Texas should be ahead of one-loss Notre Dame or if Penn State should stay ahead of Ohio State. Sorting out these teams is one of the hardest parts of the field, and it's anyone's guess how it will get sorted.
No. 11 Clemson at No. 6 Notre Dame will be an interesting matchup as well. Clemson, the unlikely ACC champion, sneaks in and plays Notre Dame. Notre Dame's offense has been dominant, ranking third in the FBS in scoring offense. But Clemson will be looking to prove themselves and make a statement in this game.
No. 10 Indiana at No. 7 Ohio State and No. 9 Tennessee at No. 8 Penn State will also be closely watched. Ohio State and Penn State have both had their ups and downs, and this will be a chance for them to redeem themselves. Tennessee will be a tough out with a strong offense and defense, and James Franklin will be looking to win a statement game for Penn State.
Alabama's road losses may work against them, but their head-to-head victory against Georgia gives them some hope. Miami has been dominant on offense but late-season losses may have hurt their chances. Ole Miss has a head-to-head victory against Georgia but other losses may be too much to overcome. South Carolina has a tough schedule and has won their last three games, but their lack of a head-to-head victory may be a deciding factor.
The College Football Playoff committee has a difficult task ahead of them as they navigate through these various issues and make their final selections. Only time will tell which teams will make it into the playoff and which ones will be left on the outside looking in.