Sarah Cinq-Mars, a fifth-grade teacher from North Carolina, embarked on her first cruise in October 2023 and has since sailed with five different cruise lines. Initially unaware of the diversity among cruise ships, Sarah discovered that each line offers unique experiences, from luxurious accommodations to world-class entertainment. Through her adventures on Royal Caribbean, Carnival, Celebrity, Princess, and Disney cruises, she gained valuable insights into what makes each line special. Her journey highlights the variety of ships, dining options, and onboard activities available, showcasing why cruisers remain loyal to their favorite brands.
Discovering the Charm of Royal Caribbean and Carnival
Sarah's maiden voyage was aboard Royal Caribbean’s Freedom of the Seas, where she experienced both the joys and challenges of cruising. Despite being an older ship, it offered memorable moments like the serene adults-only area and the delightful private island, Perfect Day at CocoCay. However, the cabin and dining experiences left much to be desired. In contrast, her Carnival cruise aboard the Elation was less favorable due to subpar cleanliness and amenities. The inside cabin lacked storage space and proper ventilation, while the dining experience was underwhelming except for the fast-casual options.
The initial excitement of stepping onto Freedom of the Seas was tempered by its age, which became evident in the cabin's design. Yet, the balcony provided breathtaking views, and the hibachi restaurant Izumi stood out as a highlight. The adults-only area offered a peaceful retreat, and CocoCay's private island experience was unparalleled. On the other hand, the Carnival Elation's interior was disappointing. The unsanitary conditions in both the cabin and common areas marred the experience, and the main dining room failed to impress. However, the fast-casual eateries were a pleasant surprise, offering tasty alternatives.
Embracing the Luxury and Entertainment of Celebrity, Princess, and Disney
Celebrity Cruises quickly became Sarah's favorite, offering spacious and beautifully designed cabins along with exceptional entertainment. The gourmet dining and lavish interiors made every moment feel special. Princess Cruises followed closely, with its stunning Sun Princess providing luxurious suites and top-notch service. Lastly, Disney Magic delivered a magical experience with its nostalgic decor and family-friendly ambiance, though the lack of a drink package was a minor drawback.
Celebrity Reflection and Ascent impressed Sarah with their spacious and elegantly designed staterooms. The infinite veranda concept, despite some temperature control issues, added a unique touch. The entertainment, including live shows and interactive activities, was nothing short of spectacular. Princess Cruises' Sun Princess, with its Cabana Mini-Suite and private deck, offered an exclusive and relaxing environment. The event staff's enthusiasm and the delicious dining options, especially at Umai, made the experience unforgettable. Finally, Disney Magic's timeless elegance and whimsical atmosphere transported guests into a world of fantasy. While the dining menu catered more to adventurous tastes, the Broadway-style shows and late-night game shows were crowd-pleasers, ensuring entertainment for all ages.