The New York Mets have made a significant move by agreeing to a two-year $34 million contract with former Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Frankie Montas. This decision comes as a bit of a surprise, especially considering the team's interest in other players like outfielder Juan Soto and pitcher Max Fried. Montas, who took his services to Cincinnati and Milwaukee last season, had a 4.84 ERA in his comeback year after a significant injury in 2023. Despite not showing a marked improvement in ERA when switching clubs at the deadline, he did see an increase in strikeout percentage, from 19.0% with the Reds to 28.7% with the Brewers.

The Mets' New Pitcher Deal and Its Implications

Montas' Past Signings and Similarities

This contract resembles the Mets' past signings of Sean Manaea and Luis Severino. These free agents weren't top of the crop in terms of stats initially, but they delivered on the mound when needed. Just like Montas, they proved their worth over time. Last season, the Mets benefited from similar pitcher deals with Luis Severino and Sean Manaea. Although both were considered overpaid by the organization initially, they led the rotation into the playoffs and an NLCS finish. This gives hope that Montas can also make a significant impact.

Montas' Role in the Mets Rotation

Frankie Montas will now look to fill the shoes of Luis Severino and Sean Manaea, who are now free agents. With Kodai Senga and David Peterson as the available starters, Montas will slot behind them. However, the Mets are expected to go for either Max Fried or Corbin Burnes to become the team's top ace. This leaves some room for adding another low-key pitcher or potentially bumping one of their prospects. It will be interesting to see how Montas fits into the team's pitching rotation and what impact he will have.

Fan Reactions and Opinions

Some Mets fans were against the deal, expressing concerns about the value and potential impact of Montas. As one fan wrote, "If Frankie Montas is worth 17 mil a year then I’m at least worth league minimum god damn." However, others were more accepting, drawing parallels to last year's successful pitcher signings. A supporter said, "This is the same “alright that’s cool I guess” feeling I had when we signed Manaea last year. Hopefully it works out the same way." Another fan in favor of the Mets boss stated, "Very reminiscent of the Sevvy and Manaea projects from last year. Stearns has earned a lot of trust on these." The diverse reactions from fans show the uncertainty and anticipation surrounding Montas' arrival in New York.