The Finance Committee of a picturesque island town has endorsed the construction of a new $105 million nursing facility, marking what could become the most expensive municipal project in local history. Despite reservations from some members regarding the financial implications, the majority agreed that the town's responsibility to care for its elderly residents outweighed fiscal concerns. The proposed 60,000-square-foot, 45-bed facility at Sherburne Commons aims to provide essential skilled nursing services on the island. This decision reflects a broader debate about balancing community welfare with long-term financial sustainability.

The proposal faced significant scrutiny during discussions. Committee member Peter N. Schaeffer, who initially opposed the project, changed his stance after engaging with staff and residents. He emphasized the moral imperative of providing a place where elderly residents can receive necessary care without being forced to relocate to the mainland. The Cape region lacks adequate facilities, making it impractical for many to find suitable alternatives nearby. Thus, the new home would serve as a final residence for those requiring specialized care, ensuring they remain close to family and friends.

Opposition to the plan was vocal, particularly from Joseph Wright, who argued that the project is fiscally irresponsible. According to projections by the town’s Finance Department, annual taxpayer contributions would increase from $5 million to $14.5 million over the next 25 years. Wright highlighted the lack of economic benefits and the potential long-term financial burden on the community. However, supporters countered that the investment is not only morally right but also necessary given the current inadequacies of the existing facility.

Select Board member Dawn Hill Holdgate stressed the importance of community support for this segment of the population. She noted that voters had previously approved a $5 million override to subsidize the operating budget of the current nursing home, indicating a willingness to invest in such services. The project would also allow Nantucket to retain its status as the only municipality in Massachusetts owning and operating its own nursing home. If approved by voters in May, construction is set to begin in June 2025, with completion expected by December 2027.

The endorsement by the Finance Committee sets the stage for a crucial vote at the upcoming Town Meeting. While the financial impact on taxpayers remains a point of contention, the committee’s decision underscores a commitment to providing compassionate care for the island’s elderly population. The proposed facility promises to offer modern amenities and better living conditions, ensuring that those in need can receive the care they deserve without leaving their community behind.