As the hot stove simmers, teams have completed their annual roster housekeeping, setting the stage for the offseason's big moves. This is the perfect time to analyze how all 30 MLB teams stack up heading into the 2025 season. The rankings below present each team as they are currently constructed, based on playing time estimates, providing a glimpse of which teams would be ready to compete if the season started today, and which ones still have work to do to get their 2025 roster in order.

Uncovering the Contenders and Rebuilders: A Comprehensive Offseason Analysis

Tier 1: Ready to Compete

The Braves and Dodgers lead the pack, boasting rosters that are among the most talented in the majors. Despite facing early-season injuries to key players in 2024, the Braves still managed to sneak into the playoffs, and they enter the offseason with the best projection in baseball. The Dodgers, fresh off their World Series triumph, are in dynasty-building mode, poised to capitalize on their star-studded roster and deep pockets to address any holes that may arise.

Tier 2: A Couple Pieces Away

The Phillies, Astros, Orioles, Yankees, and Diamondbacks all possess significant talent, but their veteran cores are quickly aging, and they'll need to navigate key departures and roster holes to remain in contention. The Phillies' window may be closing, while the Astros face the challenge of rebuilding their lineup and bullpen. The Orioles, fresh off their recent postseason appearances, are tantalizingly close to the next level, but need to fill crucial gaps. The Yankees' success hinges on their ability to re-sign Juan Soto and address other pressing needs, while the Diamondbacks must find a way to replace their departing first baseman and bolster their starting rotation.

Tier 3: Contenders in Need

The Twins, Mariners, Rangers, Royals, and Padres all have the talent to contend, but each faces unique challenges. The Twins must navigate ownership changes and roster health concerns, while the Mariners continue their quest to find the right offensive pieces to complement their strong pitching staff. The Rangers need to rebuild their bullpen and add depth to their rotation, and the Royals must find a way to build a lineup around their young core. The Padres, known for their aggressive offseason moves, must focus on building organizational depth to withstand the inevitable ups and downs of the regular season.

Tier 4: The Wide Open NL Central

The Cubs, Brewers, and Cardinals find themselves in a wide-open NL Central division, with each team facing its own set of questions. The Cubs must improve their bullpen and starting rotation depth, while the Brewers need to address the loss of Willy Adames and the back end of their rotation. The Cardinals, meanwhile, may be embarking on a short-term reset, shedding high-priced veterans in favor of a long-term strategy.

Tier 5: Lots of Work to Do

The Rays, Blue Jays, Tigers, Giants, Mets, Red Sox, and Guardians all have talented cores, but significant roster holes to fill. The Rays must navigate the transition from one core to the next, while the Blue Jays face the challenge of building a contender around Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette. The Tigers, Giants, and Mets need to be aggressive in finding ways to upgrade their rosters, while the Red Sox and Guardians must address their own unique roster challenges.

Tier 6: Laying the Foundation

The Pirates, Athletics, Marlins, Angels, Reds, and Nationals are all in various stages of rebuilding, with promising young talent but significant work ahead. The Pirates and Marlins have impressive young pitching staffs, but need to bolster their lineups, while the Athletics and Reds must rely on internal development to take the next step. The Angels and Nationals, meanwhile, are looking to build around their superstars and top prospects, with an eye towards a competitive future.

Tier 7: Perpetually Rebuilding

The White Sox and Rockies find themselves firmly entrenched in the rebuilding phase, with little hope of immediate contention. The White Sox are just beginning their rebuilding process, while the Rockies have been stuck in the baseball wilderness for years, with few signs of emerging from it.As the offseason unfolds, these power rankings will serve as a valuable tool for fans and analysts alike, providing a comprehensive snapshot of the state of the league and the challenges each team faces in their pursuit of success in the 2025 season and beyond.