The 2020 MLB draft, overshadowed by the challenges of the pandemic, has now been reevaluated through the lens of five years of hindsight. This retrospective analysis reveals how teams might have made different choices if they had known what was to come. The shortened college season and reduced draft rounds added complexity to player evaluations, but several standout performances have emerged. This article explores key players who have exceeded expectations and those whose potential remains untapped.

Emerging Stars: Redefining Top Picks

In this revised draft, some players have risen to prominence, showcasing their exceptional talent and adaptability. Spencer Strider, originally a fourth-round pick, now stands as the first choice, highlighting his impressive performance and durability. Garrett Crochet, another standout, has established himself as one of the most valuable pitchers from the 2020 class, despite limited innings early in his career. Masyn Winn's versatility and solid defensive skills position him as a top-three pick, while Patrick Bailey's elite catching abilities make him a formidable presence behind the plate.

Strider's journey from an under-the-radar prospect to a dominant force on the mound is nothing short of remarkable. His ability to harness two dynamic pitches has set him apart, leading to a fourth-place finish in the NL Cy Young Award and a second-place Rookie of the Year nod. Despite health concerns, including Tommy John surgery, Strider's impact remains undeniable. Crochet's breakout season in 2024 solidified his status as a premier reliever, boasting one of the best fastballs in the game. Winn's transition from a two-way player to a reliable shortstop has been seamless, combining offensive prowess with defensive excellence. Bailey's defensive accolades, including leading all players in fielding run value, underscore his value as a top-tier catcher.

Unrealized Potential: Reassessing Original Choices

While some players have thrived, others have faced setbacks or failed to meet initial expectations. Spencer Torkelson, once heralded as the top prospect, has struggled to translate his collegiate success to the majors. Jordan Walker, initially seen as a power-hitting third baseman, has yet to fully realize his potential. Alec Burleson's natural hitting ability has shone through, but defensive limitations have constrained his overall impact. This section delves into the challenges faced by these players and evaluates whether different drafting strategies could have altered their trajectories.

Torkelson's journey from Arizona State's star to a major league enigma highlights the difficulties of transitioning from college to professional baseball. His inconsistent performance and demotion to Triple-A in 2024 raise questions about his future role. Walker's power potential remains evident, but contact issues and defensive struggles have hindered his progress. Burleson's bat-first approach has produced solid results, but his defensive shortcomings and lack of speed limit his versatility. Evaluating these players' paths provides insights into the complexities of player development and the importance of identifying long-term fit over immediate potential.