The Rutgers Scarlet Knights faced a heartbreaking loss in the Rate Bowl, where they squandered a 17-point lead in the second half. Despite an impressive first-half performance, the team struggled to maintain momentum, ultimately falling to Kansas State 44-41. This outcome highlighted both the promise and challenges facing the program as it looks toward the future. The defense faltered significantly, while the offense demonstrated potential that could be built upon.
Defense Under Scrutiny: Addressing Key Concerns
The defensive unit's struggles were evident in their inability to contain Kansas State's explosive offense, which amassed 542 total yards. In particular, running back Dylan Edwards dominated with 196 rushing yards, including a pivotal 65-yard touchdown run early in the third quarter. These performances underscored the need for substantial improvements and leadership changes within the defense.
The departure of defensive coordinator Joe Harasymiak adds another layer of complexity. Coach Greg Schiano acknowledged the impact of losing Harasymiak but emphasized the importance of finding the right replacement rather than rushing the decision. Several key players, including linebacker Tyreem Powell and defensive end Aaron Lewis, are set to leave the team. However, promising talent remains, albeit relatively inexperienced. Overcoming these challenges will be crucial for the new coordinator. Injuries have also played a significant role in the defense's underperformance throughout the season, complicating efforts to build consistency. Despite rebuilding efforts during the bye week, the defense still faces critical questions heading into the next season.
Offensive Bright Spots: Building Momentum for the Future
On the offensive side, Rutgers showed remarkable progress. Quarterback Athan Kaliakmanis continued his development, leading the team to score at least 30 points in its final four games. Freshman Antwan Raymond filled in admirably for star running back Kyle Monangai, who opted out of the bowl game, contributing 113 yards and three touchdowns. Receivers Ian Strong and KJ Duff also made significant contributions.
The offense's success this season marked a turning point for the Scarlet Knights. They averaged 28.9 points per game, the highest since 2008. With returning talent like quarterback Kaliakmanis and promising freshmen, the future looks bright. Additional reinforcements, such as transfer running back CJ Campbell Jr. and receiver DT Sheffield, will further bolster the roster. Wide receiver Christian Dremel, a veteran player, expressed optimism about the offense's growth over the past two years. As Rutgers prepares for the 2025 season, addressing defensive weaknesses while building on offensive strengths will be paramount to achieving sustained success.