As the Pittsburgh Pirates gear up for the 2024-25 offseason, the search for a first base upgrade has become a recurring theme. With offense being the primary focus for General Manager Ben Cherington, the team's attention turns to the trade market, where a potential partnership with the Baltimore Orioles could yield valuable assets.

Uncovering the Gems: The Orioles' Offensive Powerhouses

Ryan Mountcastle: The Steady Offensive Performer

Ryan Mountcastle, the 27-year-old first baseman, has been a consistent producer for the Orioles over the past five seasons. Despite playing in the cavernous confines of Camden Yards, Mountcastle has managed to showcase his offensive prowess, hitting .271 with a .733 OPS, 30 doubles, two triples, 13 home runs, and 63 RBIs in 2023. His ability to maintain an above-average offensive performance year after year, coupled with his defensive improvements, make him an intriguing target for the Pirates. With Mountcastle's arbitration-eligible status and team control through 2026, he could provide the Pirates with a long-term solution at first base.

Ryan O'Hearn: The Breakout Bat from Baltimore

Alongside Mountcastle, the Pirates may also have their sights set on Ryan O'Hearn, the 31-year-old first baseman who has found his stride with the Orioles. After a slow start to his career with the Kansas City Royals, O'Hearn has blossomed in Baltimore, slashing .275/.329/.450 with 43 doubles, four triples, 29 home runs, and 119 RBIs over the past two seasons. While his defensive skills may not be as polished as Mountcastle's, O'Hearn's offensive prowess could make him an enticing option for the Pirates. With an $8 million club option for 2025 and free agency looming, O'Hearn's contract situation could be a factor in the Pirates' decision-making process.

Balancing the Scales: The Orioles' Pitching Needs

As the Pirates explore potential trade options with the Orioles, the equation extends beyond just the offensive upgrades. The Orioles, too, have their own needs to address, particularly in the starting pitching department. With ace Corbin Burnes set to hit free agency, the Orioles will be in the market for quality arms to bolster their rotation. This presents an opportunity for the Pirates, who possess a wealth of starting pitching depth both at the major league level and in their minor league system.

A History of Collaboration: The Pirates-Orioles Trade Connection

The Pirates and Orioles have a recent history of collaboration, having completed a trade at the 2023 deadline that saw the Pirates acquire outfielder Billy Cook in exchange for right-hander Patrick Reilly. This established rapport between the two organizations could pave the way for further negotiations, as General Manager Ben Cherington looks to leverage the Pirates' strengths to address their needs at first base.

Navigating the Contract Landscape: Balancing Costs and Control

As the Pirates weigh their options, the contract situations of both Mountcastle and O'Hearn will play a crucial role. Mountcastle, with his projected $6.6 million salary for 2024 and team control through 2026, represents a longer-term investment, while O'Hearn's $8 million club option for 2025 and impending free agency may present a more immediate, yet potentially more cost-effective, solution. The Pirates will need to carefully evaluate the financial implications and the long-term benefits of each player to determine the best fit for their roster and budget.

Unlocking the Potential: Maximizing the Pirates' Strengths

The Pirates' depth in starting pitching could prove to be a valuable bargaining chip in their negotiations with the Orioles. By leveraging their surplus of talented arms, the Pirates may be able to secure the offensive upgrades they seek without compromising their long-term plans. This strategic approach could not only address the team's needs at first base but also strengthen the overall roster, positioning the Pirates for a potential playoff push in 2025.