Baseball
Winter Meetings Reveal Starting Pitchers Are in High Demand
2024-12-13
ESPN baseball reporter Alden Gonzalez delves into the intriguing trend of starting pitchers commanding hefty contracts in today's baseball landscape. With Juan Soto's massive deal as a backdrop, subsequent transactions have shed light on a more revealing pattern. The winter meetings at the Hilton hotel became a stage for these developments, as teams and agents grappled with the changing dynamics of the game.
Unraveling the Mystery of Rising Starting Pitcher Salaries
Section 1: The Impact of Juan Soto's Contract
The enormity of Juan Soto's 15-year, $765 million contract brought an initial shock to the winter meetings. It was a monumental deal that stood out due to its uniqueness. Landing one of history's greatest hitters in his mid-20s is a rare occurrence. This contract set the stage for a reevaluation of the value placed on starting pitchers. As subsequent transactions unfolded, it became clear that starting pitchers were getting their due.Even in an era of heavy bullpen usage, starting pitchers who can consistently pitch five to six innings and around 160 innings over a six-month season are still crucial. Their scarcity has triggered a demand that has driven up prices. This was exemplified by Max Fried signing an eight-year, $218 million deal with the New York Yankees, blowing away projections. Nathan Eovaldi also secured a three-year, $75 million contract to return to the Texas Rangers, doubling his prior guarantee. Alex Cobb, a 37-year-old with a litany of injuries, received a one-year, $15 million deal, showing that it's not just the top starters getting paid.Section 2: Theories Behind the Pay Surge
Executives, agents, and coaches surveyed during the winter meetings offered various theories. One general manager noted that these starters are just as important, even in an era of bullpen reliance. Their rarity leads to increased demand and higher prices. Another pointed to big-market teams chasing top-tier free agents and how it affects those below them. The New York Mets' signing of Frankie Montas to a two-year, $34 million deal was seen by some as an overpay, setting a tone.Most conversations, however, came back to the rapid rate of arm injuries that have plagued the industry. Teams are now hyper-paranoid about their starting pitching depth. Once, teams felt good with seven or eight reliable starters. Now, that number has increased to around 11. The Yankees, with a solid fivesome already, added Max Fried after missing out on Soto. The Dodgers, who won the World Series, focused on Blake Snell despite having a strong rotation. The impact of injuries on teams' depth is a significant factor in the rising salaries.Section 3: The Alarm Bells of Pitcher Injuries
The breadth of pitcher injuries has been a concern for over a decade. A presentation at the winter meetings shed new light on this issue. The sport's 30 managers gathered as MLB officials presented key findings from a year-long study involving over 200 experts. Slides showed that surgeries to repair damaged ulnar collateral ligaments at the minor league level have nearly doubled in the past 10 years. Current major league pitchers and the talent behind them are both breaking down.One manager in attendance described the findings as "stunning." The trade market was still active as agents and executives headed home. Teams seeking alternatives to high free agent prices are interested in Dylan Cease, Pablo López, Framber Valdez, Jesús Luzardo, and Luis Castillo. The Baltimore Orioles, Toronto Blue Jays, Mets, and San Francisco Giants are among those still in search of frontline starting pitching.Section 4: The Current Offseason Spending
A dozen starting pitchers have signed for a combined $788.5 million in the first five weeks of the offseason, already about 63% of last year's spending. Corbin Burnes is expected to exceed $200 million, and Jack Flaherty, Sean Manaea, Nick Pivetta, Walker Buehler, Max Scherzer, and Justin Verlander are among the other available starters. Despite concerns about early deal inflation, one thing is clear: starting pitching, which was out of vogue in the modern game, is still in high demand.Teams are willing to invest in starting pitchers as they recognize their importance in a game where depth is crucial. The winter meetings have been a window into this changing landscape, and the impact is likely to be felt throughout the baseball season.